
One of the most common loan structuring errors I come across—happening in roughly 90% of cases—is mixing loans. This occurs when a single loan is used for multiple purposes, usually due to redraw facilities being accessed incorrectly. While it might seem harmless at first, mixing loans can create major tax and financial headaches down the line.
Example: David’s Costly Redraw Decision
David took out an $800,000 loan from a bank to purchase his $1,000,000 home. Over time, he paid down the balance to $600,000, leaving $200,000 available in redraw. Since this loan was originally for his owner-occupied home, it is considered non-deductible.
Later, David decides to invest in property. Instead of using his own savings, he redraws $200,000 from this existing loan to cover the deposit for his investment purchase. Now, his loan has become a mix of personal and investment debt.
At this stage, everything might still seem fine—but here’s where problems begin.
Issue #1: Reduced Tax Benefits
If David’s loan is structured as principal and interest (P&I), every repayment he makes will reduce both the investment and private portions at the same rate. Because he can’t control where his repayments go, the investment portion will gradually shrink along with the private portion, reducing the amount of tax-deductible interest he can claim.
The Fix: Before using redraw for an investment, always split the loan first.
Issue #2: Complex Accounting
Managing a mixed-purpose loan gets messy quickly. Every payment David makes must be divided proportionally between the personal and investment portions.
For example, if his $800,000 loan is split 75% private ($600,000) and 25% investment ($200,000), a $1,000 repayment would reduce the investment debt by $250 and the private debt by $750. While this may be easy to track at first, once interest accrues and more repayments are made, keeping accurate records becomes nearly impossible.
The Fix: Avoid the hassle by structuring loans properly before redrawing.
Issue #3: Inefficient Offset Account Usage
An offset account could make things even worse. Since David’s entire loan is mixed, any funds in offset reduce interest across both portions. If he has $600,000 in offset, he’s still paying interest on $200,000 of debt, and 75% of those interest savings are wasted on the personal loan instead of maximizing deductions on the investment loan.
The Fix: By setting up two separate loans—one for $600,000 (private) and one for $200,000 (investment)—David could link his offset to the private loan and eliminate non-deductible interest entirely.
Issue #4: Complications When Selling
If David decides to sell either his home or the investment property, he’ll need to carefully handle his loans. Selling his home, for instance, could mean needing to pay off the investment portion since it was secured against that property. This could impact his tax deductions.
The Fix: A properly structured loan from the start provides more flexibility when selling a property.
Already Have a Mixed Loan? Here's What to Do
The ATO does allow mixed loans to be separated. While you can’t undo past mistakes, you can "unmix" a loan by calculating the respective portions and formally splitting them into separate accounts. This way, private and investment debts are clearly defined, making tax deductions easier to manage.
The Bottom Line
Mixed loans create unnecessary complications and can lead to lost tax benefits. The best approach? Always separate your loans before using redraw for an investment. This simple step can save you money, simplify tax reporting, and give you better financial control.
Disclaimer
This material has been prepared for information purposes ONLY, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on without Tax/Accounting/Legal/Financial/Credit advice from a relevant qualified adviser.
